Friday, October 25, 2013

RNO: TFC's seven years of poor spending for Leiweke et al. to overcome

Canadian Men's National Team

 
Posted by Aaron Nielsen, 
October 17, 2013
Email 
Aaron Nielsen

Twitter
@ENBSports
 
Read this on your iPhone/iPad or Android device 
qrcode
Share
 
 
The salary cap has existed in professional North American sports since the 1984-85 NBA season when they adopted a strict cap of $3.5 Million a team per season. Since then, a number of leagues have implemented similar systems including the NHL, NFL, CFL, a number of World Rugby Leagues, Aussie Rule Football and of course Major League Soccer. Mistakes in managing a salary cap are frequent and with the amount of money now being thrown around you see a number of horrible one-off deals. When evaluating the history of the salary cap in team sports, it could be argued that Toronto FC has been the worst club ever in managing this type of system.


Failing to make the playoffs, over a seven year period that has included a total of 50 wins, shows this ineptness, but even more damaging to Toronto’s past management is that during this time TFC had one of the highest payrolls in the league. Since 2007, Toronto FC has paid players a guaranteed salary of $33,202,884. This is third highest behind Los Angeles (which includes the Beckham, Keane & Donovan contracts) and the New York Red Bulls (this includes Henry, Cahill and Marquez contracts). In comparison, playoff regulars Seattle totaled $24,761,713 (including Dempsey), Real Salt Lake $20,071,454, Houston $20,411,038 and San Jose $16,942,986. The only team comparable to Toronto is Chicago who have spent $32,399,721, but have also made the playoffs four times and won 133 regular season games over the same period of time.


In analyzing this history of failure is the amount of money Toronto was willing to give players, or accept bad contracts from other clubs in the league. DP's have taken a big cut of the total with Danny Koevermans getting a guaranteed $4.6M, Julian De Guzman another $4.6M, and Torsten Frings $3.5M, and we can't forget Mista who was given $987,337 to play nine games and then retire from football. These four players combined for 134 career Toronto FC games, scoring a combined 22 goals with Kovemans getting 17 of them. I would say that many clubs have had issues with DP's, evaluating DP's value, and they have been one of the worst investments on the pitch. However, regarding MLS, what it meant off the pitch might be another story.


I can forgive Toronto FC for overspending on DP's, but some of the contracts they gave for other players to join the club is a greater issue. For example, English Championship skilled players such as Carl Robinson, who was given $315K, and in his career $960K, for 74 games and later played 12 games with New York before he retired. $436K to Darren O'Dea for 26 games and who is now in the Ukraine, and not to mention the first signing, Jim Brennan who played 84 games and made $534K in three seasons. They spent a further $212K for Rohan Ricketts, who after his 39 games with Toronto, has traveled the world playing non-league quality football. Andrew Welsh was on for $205K, who after his 20 games in Toronto continued his career in the English third division of football. This trend continued this season, and even Robert Earnshaw's $155K a year is more reasonable, but at that price there should be better options.


Outside the lower leagues of England, TFC hasn't done any better with players such as Carlos Ruiz getting $460K, Pablo Vitti $303K, Laurent Robert $250K, Peri Marosevic $129K, and Collin Samuel $115K. All of whom never proved to be worth those salaries with Toronto, or since leaving the club. Newer signings Alvaro Rey on $200K, Jeremy Brockie $175K, Jonas Elmer on $130K are also in this salary range. We have yet to see what Rey and Elmer could do, but based on Toronto's track record of signing, over paying and being disappointed by the results, it doesn't look good. 


Toronto has also have had a history of taking bad contracts from other MLS clubs. The worst probably being the Eric Hassli deal with Vancouver which included next year's first round pick in return. However, in terms of cap space, others caused similar problems regarding team development, including taking $270K of salary for Ronnie O'Brien, $232K for Jeff Cunningham, $200K for Nick Garcia, $150K for Tyrone Marshall and $131K for Adrian Serioux. These players all gave minutes but didn't prove to be the permanent piece expected with these type of salaries. A good example of this in 2013 is Bobby Convey who is currently on $215K guarantee salary. Despite his improving play, Toronto is still not getting what is expected from a player in that salary range.


Finally, Toronto FC has given lucrative contracts to players that went beyond the player's value. Chad Barrett was paid $61K in 2008 and then paid $202K by Toronto in 2009 and 2010. A more recent case is Richard Eckersley going from $90K in 2011, which was the top range for a full back, and is currently on $300K, while Stefen Frei’s salary has consistently risen from $120K in 2009 to $200k this season, despite being plagued by injuries.
The reality is this is not only a Toronto FC concern, as American/Canadian based players will get salary increases each season based on how many years they have played in the league. However, team management needs to be aware of this and not overvalue players purely based on loyalty.


Players currently in the $200K range in MLS include Sebastian Le Toux, Nat Bochers, Nick Rimando, Osvaldo Alonso, Claudio Bieler and Mike Magee to name a few, while Toronto FC killers Dominic Oduro and C.J. Sapong are on $122K and $92K respectfully.


With such large salaries given to so many players it also means Toronto had a high number of players at very low salaries. Ironically Toronto didn't seem give them the fair share of the deal despite the contract relief they've provided. Nana Attakora averaged $24.9K over 4 years, Milos Kocic $42K over 3 years, Joao Plata $48K over 2 years, Sam Cronnin $60K, Luis Silva $79K – a couple of these players demonstrate to you the value of the draft. Currently there are a number of players at this range, including players who have given the club great value for service and it’s in important for Toronto FC’s future to properly understand the true value of these current resources especially players who make under $100K a season.


I apologize for recounting bad memories for many Toronto FC fans and I'm sure I'm going to hear examples of other poor franchises in sports. They are in a city with both the Toronto Raptors and Toronto Maple Leafs, although comparably I would relate Toronto FC’s failure more closely to the Blue Jays 2013 season based on the resources of the club. The last seven years TFC should of been favorites, or close to it each season, yet they continue to finish out of the playoffs and close to the bottom. While money doesn't mean success, it does mean opportunities, which in my view Toronto FC has failed with more so than any other team in professional sports.

RNO: TFC's current direction raises concerns and little optimism

Canadian Men's National Team


Posted by Aaron Nielsen,
August 3, 2013
Email 
Aaron Nielsen

Twitter
@ENBSports
Read this on your iPhone/iPad or Android device 
qrcode
Share
 
I will freely give my opinion, and I'll even be a smart ass, but what I don't tend to do is get angry about anything, especially if it's out of my own control. Except in the instance where the mistake is not only hurting the one who is making it but also all the people who care for it. This is my current view of Toronto FC with the continuous talk of improvement and new players, the releasing of parts, be it draft pick or players for allocation money, and the team's most recent signings.
I will admit being angry at Toronto FC reminds me of knowing a drug addict who you watch deteriorate: first you laugh about it as you don't think it's serious, then you ignore problem as it's embarrassing, until it reaches the point of sadness where there is little chance of reclaiming lost days of past, while those hopes and great expectations deeply affects those who feel obligated to care about it.
My anger goes beyond the losing team, the fact that season tickets for Bayern Munich (among other teams) are cheaper than Toronto FC, and the fact management has gone out of their way to kill the once exciting atmosphere that was once the talk of the league. My anger is the fact by that management's choice in actions are making the situation worse not only for the short term but the foreseeable future as well.
Without even mentioning the marketing/business departments, and concentrating purely on the field, my anger comes from the fact that I, or I could imagine almost anybody who attends games and understand the basics of MLS, could do a better job. Hiring an experienced coach who understands the league, drafting the most high profiles players at each draft, signing and trading for players who have a proven record of success in the league, and if you are going to bring players in from abroad, you bring in someone you have heard about or at least playing on a club you heard of.
Toronto FC rebuild number twelve (I'm sure many have lost count, but assuming two every season) seems to be following the most recent, and short term success of the Montreal Impact. The basic idea being any player in Europe is better than an American/Canadian, work from defensive standpoint because you can't lose in a 0-0 scoreline, and then hopefully bring in a DP striker who you'll rely all your offense on. If he scores a goal a game you have a chance to win, and if he's a bust you can blame the team failures on him. This is not aimed as a criticism at Montreal as I wrote in my preseason write-up of the Impact that they are an MLS experiment with many things I like. Patrice Bernier has been a star in the MLS, while Marco Di Vaio and Alessandro Nesta were two of the top players in Italy while playing in Serie A.
In my preseason synopsis of the Impact I wrote it’s great to sign experienced players, but in a restricted budget environment it is hard to be consistently good if your team lacks depth. Personally, I like some of the moves the Impact have made, although I still predict Montreal to struggle to make the playoffs this season. The big worry is if the experiment doesn't pay off, with a club developed in this fashion, "where do you go next?"
So far in 2013 the experiment has paid off and Montreal have been the surprise team the first half of the season, although they are still only 5 points ahead of the teams out of the playoffs, and with the CONCACAF Champion League games to play I still have concerns about them making the playoffs. The other difference between Montreal and Toronto is despite my concerns, Montreal still maintains some core MLS/North American depth in Patrice Bernier, Justin Mapp, Collen Warner, Jeb Brovsky and Andrew Wenger, while Blake Smith has been a useful draft pick playing seven more games then Kyle Bekker and Emory Welshman has combined for Toronto.
This might not be important to the fan watching the team play, however, this is key in building a long-term successful MLS club and by doing Toronto's current model in signing of average foreign players over college-based players means you sacrifice assets and team consistency. The main reason is most American/Canadian based MLS entry players drafted sign a three year contracts with the club, while foreign players sign for a season and some even for 6 months.
Which means American/Canadian based college players who sign to these long term contracts can be traded to other teams for attributes, where foreign players leave on free transfer and in many cases in MLS history will return to where they came from once an opportunity presents itself. So by ignoring MLS precedents and not taking advantage of the MLS system, each season you are basically left with an empty shell of a team and now you have to try to fill a roster each season with a bunch of foreign and semi-pro players that no one has ever heard of before who will accept 50K a year to basically eat minutes.
Which brings me back to Toronto. If you remove the foreign players on short contracts the only living things left in the TFC shell are Matias Laba, a holding midfielder at best under the name of a DP. Bobby Convey, a player making 200K and based on good MLS economics will most likely be cut at seasons end. Jonathan Osorio who has been the story of 2013, although has only played 853 minutes and only had five shots on target, and at this point still hard to tell what he would be as a full-time, season long regular.
Ashtone Morgan, who I still feel has potential but looks like the next one to leave with the signing of Jonas Elmer, and the disappointing and falling stock of Gale Agbossoumonde, Kyle Bekker, Emery Welshman and some might even say Doneil Henry. TFC also has no 2014 MLS draft first round pick which they traded to Vancouver, no third round pick which they traded to Kansas City and no player eligible for Homegrown status. Even the much maligned Chivas USA, who very much are in the same boat, still has Dan Kennedy, Carlos Bocanegra, Tristan Bowen, Carlos Alverez, Caleb Calvert, Josue Soto, and Jose Correa.
So based on teams assets, it's very difficult not to look ahead and say next season Toronto FC will be very much like this season's team: a collection of current roster players trying to keep a job in football or a new crew of out of work players across small teams and leagues in Europe and South America, chosen by a team with no proof of proper scouting and a league who is equally as bad at recruiting players.
Which means either another horrible season in the bottom of the league or the paying of multiple millions of dollars for a high profile DP. Although even then, based on league history, expect the team to be average at best and again most likely missing out on the playoffs. Unless there is drastic change performed by a miracle worker, from what we have to work with expect the future to be difficult as well.
Worst of all like the drug user metaphor, expect MLSE to pretend everything is fine, give more and more false promises and continue to lower the expectations from the people who care. Yes, I'm angry because Toronto FC and MLSE have an addiction to failure and they are not only hurting themselves but upsetting people who's only wish is for Toronto FC to succeed.

RNO: Another TFC overhaul. Have they learned from past mistakes?

Canadian Men's National Team


Posted by Aaron Nielsen,
July 16, 2013
Email 
Aaron Nielsen

Twitter
@ENBSports
Read this on your iPhone/iPad or Android device 
qrcode
Share
 
What can you say about a team that only has seven total shots on target in eighteen games from the midfield? Either the team is playing some weird 6-1-3 formation or the team is very bad. TFC haven't played a 6-1-3 this year, so yes, they are very bad. Despite only doing slightly worse than projected in the standings, the team has done it in a very boring, and in many ways, a scared fashion.


Let’s be honest. Like Johnston, Preki, Klinsmann (to a different extent), Winter, and Mariner, MLSE have been scammed again by a coach who was totally unprepared and provides zero assets to the club, as well as by a new President and General Manager whose greatest skill is knowing when to leave a sinking ship. DC United, who by the way last won the title almost 10 years ago, are probably the only greater disappointment this season than the Reds.


Why does this keep on happening? Well part of this is easily blamed up top by a group of individuals who are stuck between knowing nothing and thinking they are making the right decision. Although in this situation, despite their great support, I can almost blame the fan base as much as anybody.


I joined twitter two years ago, and since I happen to watch most Toronto FC games when on television, I tweet along with the hashtag #TFClive. I try to be funny, I try to be smart, but mostly what I am is honest. During these last two seasons I've made many comments directed towards Toronto FC ineptitude and acquisition of players such as Cann, Plata, Johnson, Lambe, Henry, Bekker, and Welshman, with the basic point these players are what they are and in many cases not good enough for MLS. In almost every case I will get a counter tweet saying “these players are great”, “why am I hating”, and so on, with the greatest back and forth being about Aaron Winter's 4-3-3 and how Toronto FC is developing themselves to be the next Barcelona.


After looking in the mirror and realizing our mistakes I'm now willing to start over, and based on the current dismantling of the team it seems Toronto FC wants to this as well. In comes Tim Leiweke, the man given a lot of credit for the turnaround of the LA Galaxy. A team who missed the playoffs three years in a row from 2006, to finishing last during the 2008 season, and now has won back to back championships. In Toronto’s case there is already talk about bringing in a huge DP with Diego Forlan being the name on everyone’s mind. Let’s continue with this optimism and try to figure out how Toronto FC can become a competitive team going for the championship in the foreseeable future.


Admittedly, Toronto FC are worse off than LA were in 2009. The 2009 Galaxy had a 27 year old Landon Donovan and Alan Gordon, they also drafted Omar Gonzalez and AJ De La Garza during the 2009 SuperDraft, and took Sean Franklin 4th overall the year before. On a side note, I ask all who follow MLS closely, wouldn't Andrew Farrell, Carlos Alvarez, Kekuta Manneh, Deshorn Brown, Walker Zimmerman, or Dillon Powers look great in a Toronto FC jersey right now? They also brought in of course David Beckham, as well as some quality MLS players in Donovan Ricketts, Mike Magee, and Todd Dunivant, orchestrated by probably the greatest coach in American soccer history, Bruce Arena. 


My first suggestion for the big fix, with long term success, is the need to bring in someone who understands the league and player development to coach and run the team. My view has always been current Maryland soccer coach Sasho Cirovski would be the perfect fit for Toronto, although now I'm thinking the problem is too big for him. Toronto would have to spend a large amount of money to steal a Bruce Arena, Sigi Schmid, Dominic Kinnear or even a Jason Kreis from one of the successful teams in the league.


Second it’s the DP, and let's for argument sake say it is Diego Forlan. Personally, I think he would do well in MLS, although I question that he can be convinced to come. Currently, he is one of the top goalscorers in Brazil Serie A, who will be a championship contender this season. He is also making a reported $2.5 million US dollars to play in Brazil. If he was to come to Toronto the biggest question in my mind is who will provide a partnership service to him? If I was in charge, I would also attempt to bring in a companion player, hopefully not a DP. Forlan’s current teammate at Internacional, Andrés D'Alessandro, is a good example. Or the Portuguese international Simao Sabrosa, who played many games with Forlan at Athletico Madrid and is now a bit time player in Spain, is potentially another great choice.
Andres D'Alessandro is a 32-year old Argentinean attacking midfielder who has
been playing with Forlan’s current club Internacional since 2008. He was
voted South American player of the year in 2010, leading his team to a Copa
Libertadores championship. Prior, he played for River Plate and San Lorenzo
in Argentina, Wolfsburg in the Bundesliga, Portsmouth in the Premier League
and Zaragoza in Spain. Overall, he's played 359 career league games scoring
69 goals and 66 assists. He also played with the Argentina National Team 28 
times. He still is Internacional’s captain and if Toronto is able to get
 Forlan, there is no reason D'Alessandro wouldn't have an interest as well.


Simao Sabrosa, who is 33, would be known by anybody who follows Portuguese
 soccer, being capped by his national team 88 times scoring 22 goals. For his
 club career, Simao has played for Sporting, Barcelona, Benfica, Aletico 
Madrid, Bestiktas, and most recently Espanyol, scoring 122 goals in 456
games, mostly from an attacking midfield or winger position. Simao played
with Forlan between 2007-2011, which were Forlan’s most successful seasons in
his career, including a UEFA Europa League championship in 2010. Simao is on
a yearly contract with Espanyol so could leave on a free if he chose to do
so.


Other lesser known alternatives who provide the same skill sets at a much
 cheaper price could be Argentinians Juan Eluchans and David Ramírez,
 Paraguayan Carlos Paredes, Uruguayan Mario 
Regueiro, Polish player Sebastian Mila or Egyptian Mohamed Aboutreika, only to name a few. Yes, all over 30, and in many ways looking for a pay day, but
 have also had successful careers including their recent season and whose main
 skill has been one of a threat and provider from midfield - something Toronto
 FC’s current side lacks the most.

So we now have the nucleus of team who can improve the overall return from players such as Earnshaw, Koevermans, Eckersley, Caldwell and Laba. Although one of the smartest things the LA Galaxy have done in their team development is let the young players play and through this experience these players have become MLS ready. So my new look Toronto FC side would be GK: Bendrik (Frei); Defenders: Morgan, Agbossoumonde, Caldwell, Eckersley; Midfielders: Laba, Osorio, Convey (Bekker); Attackers: Forlan, Simao/D'Alessandro, Koevermans (Earnshaw).


The other key is that the MLS is not a sprint or a marathon. It’s about being successful at the right time. With the playoff system all you need to get during the season is somewhere between 40-44 points, which means Toronto would need 10 wins in the final 16 games. This would also make Toronto the hottest team going into the playoffs, which has proven to be a great omen for MLS championships.
Last season the MLS Cup final was played between LA and Houston who finished 8th and 9th during the regular season. Now will this happen or is it even possible? Probably not, but the moral of the story is Toronto FC needs to look at the big picture and make drastic changes with a proven track record. Now is the time, in the midst of another overhaul, instead of thinking it's doing something right, failing, and putting us through another horrible attempt, because at the current pace soon enough there will not be any team, or fans, at all.

RNO: Analyzing the Montreal Impact's road to the playoffs

Canadian Men's National Team


Posted by Aaron Nielsen,
September 26, 2013
Email 
Aaron Nielsen

Twitter
@ENBSports
Read this on your iPhone/iPad or Android device 
qrcode
Share
 
With Toronto FC's on-the-field season all but complete for 2013, I thought I would give my attention to the Montreal Impact. After three difficult games that lead to losses, there is some concern regarding the club, having not advanced in the Champions League (despite winning 2-0 at home against C.D. Heredia) and even more concerns about making the playoffs.
Statistically Montreal should make the post-season based on their position in the table and strength of schedule. Montreal play homes games against playoff rivals New England and Philadelphia, who the Impact have done well against and are statistically projected to get four to six points from those games. Their away games are against Chicago, Houston and Los Angeles, where they are projected to gain two to three points, while their final game is in Toronto. A win against TFC should give the Impact 56 points, which would keep them 3rd in the Eastern Conference, and at least seven points in the six games to guarantee a playoff spot. 
Third place is important as it would mean the Impact would get a 1st round bye and a conference semi-final home/away fixture with either Sporting KC or the New York Red Bulls. Montreal won two of three in the season series against KC, while losing two out of three to New York. They will likely be perceived as underdogs in both series, although an interesting note of the three loses against these teams is that Nesta missed two of those games. As I detailed in my preseason preview of the Impact, there has been a great dependency on Nesta. The Impact are 11 wins, 5 draws and 5 losses with a 1.38 goals against average with him in the line up, while in MLS games where he hasn't played, they have won twice, drew one and lost four games with a 1.85 goals against average.
The other dependency has been Marco Di Vaio, as his 18 goals and two assists counts for 43% of the Impacts offense. Compared to Thierry Henry's 9 goals and 8 assists amounting to 37% of the Red Bulls offense, while Sporting KC's Claudio Bieler's 10 goals and 4 assists is 33% of his club's offense. Di Vaio also has more than 1/3 of Montreal's shots, but he also had his greatest struggles against KC, where in three games he played 258 minutes, scored zero goals, had one assist and only one shot on target. He scored 2 goals on 5 shots on target in three games against New York, however, in his most dominating game against the Red Bulls where he had a goal and three shots on target, Jamison Olave didn't play.
Another key element of the Impact's success is their midfield where veterans Patrice Bernier, Justin Mapp and Davy Arnoud have demonstrated the value of proven commodities in this league. Felipe has also shown an ability to spark the offense with 5 goals and 6 assists, but one could argue his influence on the game has been less than in 2012 primarily from his ability to draw fewer fouls this season. Andres Romero has performed adequately based on his $48,000 salary, however, he's only scored 2 goals and had 5 shots on target, while new signing Hernan Bernardello has yet to make the influence as expected and been dealing with injuries.
New signing Piscu has also been injured and has yet to make his Montreal Impact debut while regulars Matteo Ferrari, Hassoun Camara, Jeb Brovsky have performed well partnered with Nesta. In net, Troy Perkins is a veteran keeper with over 185 MLS games under his belt and important playoff experience when he played for DC United. That being said, Montreal currently have the worst goals allowed per game of any team in a playoff position. One reason for this is they have allowed five penalty kicks, but interestingly enough, they committed the least fouls in the league - almost 100 less than Toronto. One issue is they have been prone to counter attacks, especially when trailing, which the Impact need to be aware of in the playoffs as they will be playing a two-leg aggregate series during the first two rounds. 
Through all of this, Montreal's biggest concern approaching the playoffs is their lack of bench depth. The main issue is support up front where statistically Daniele Paponi has provided the most offense with 2 goals and 1 assist, although the team is under .500 when he plays with 5 wins, 7 losses and 3 draws. Sanna Nyassi, who was an asset in 2012 with 6 goals only has one this season, while Collen Warner, Andrea Pisanu, Andrew Wenger, Blake Smith and Karl Ouimette, based on the lack of minutes, don't show much trust from the coach. This might be a huge blow in Montreal's playoff success as post-season games come quickly, where a club could be required to play as many as four games in ten days.
At the beginning of the season I thought the Impact would struggle to make the playoffs, however by team/player performance they have done as I expected and it's been the struggles of DC United, Chicago and Houston that has allowed them to be in the position they are in now. I think the Impact have done very well, which Toronto can learn from, in creating a key MLS core while the higher profile players have performed well when healthy.
The question for Montreal heading into October and possibly even November is do they have enough to win the seven or eight more games needed to lift an MLS championship? Even if they don't, from a sports fan living in Toronto I would dream for just the opportunity.

RNO: An Analytical Preview of the Montreal Impact for 2013

Stade Saputo


Posted by Aaron Nielsen,
February 27, 2013
Email 
Aaron Nielsen

Twitter
@ENBSports
Read this on your iPhone/iPad or Android device 
qrcode
Share
 
As a statistician exploring new ideas, I understand the issues of publicly trying out an experiment. It can either go great and help create your identity or be a complete failure where you look like a fool for even attempting it. This is how I see the development of the Montreal Impact - an experiment, going against all most popular theories in how to develop a successful team in the MLS and trying to be the first club since Chicago in 1998 to be a competitive expansion team. Chicago actually won both the league and US Cup their first season in the league, although the league was only three years old at the time. Montreal will be happy with playoffs in 2013 and, although the Eastern Division is weaker than the West, the Impact will need many of their risks to pay off to attain this result.

Here is my Projected/Expected statistical analysis of the Montreal Impact:

Goalkeeping
Troy Perkins 
Last season Montreal traded Donovan Ricketts for Troy Perkins and statistically Perkins was more effective with a 0.89 Goals Against Average and a .813 save percentage compared to Rickets 1.64/.630. Now part of the reason for this is Perkins played when Nesta started, so although Perkins is a good keeper, it’s how organized the Impact defense is that will be the effect on how many goals are allowed.

Full-Backs
Jeb Brovsky

Last season, Montreal fullbacks were usually a traditional MLS affair in Brovsky and Valentin and Wahl and Gardner. Although Brovsky and Valentin remain, the starting full backs in 2013 will be Camara on the right and Iapichino on the left, both with European experience. Camara is actually the Montreal defender with the most local experience after playing with Montreal NASL club in 2011. Iapichino will have familiarity with new head coach Schallibaum, as both participated in the second division of Switzerland. Neither players are proven and, other than filling minutes, I would say much isn't expected from them other than maintaining a traditional Italian style back four.

Centre-Back
Allesandro Nesta

Nesta has been a sensational player defensively and in the MLS he should be a great leader, although even in his prime he was never a threat, playing most of the games in his own half. While his partner Mateo Ferrari doesn't have the calmness of his fellow Italian International, historically he has played the exact same style. Which basically means Montreal management feel the Italian style of defense is the best in the world. That might be true. The issue is that most countries in the world, including the MLS, don't play Italian style football. This, in my opinion, creates two issues. Montreal is basically ignoring any offensive contribution by the defense, especially on set plays. Furthermore, what happens if one of the starting four miss games and are replaced by an American/Canadian defender who doesn't have a similar upbringing. This being said, the health of Nelson Rivas might be vital for the Impact as the season rolls along.

Defensive Midfield
Patrice Bernier

Based on Montreal best lineup through projected stats, I have the Impact playing a 4-1-4-1 formation with Canadian Patrice Bernier playing the role of holding midfielder. Bernier was what Toronto expected from De Guzman years before as the main passing route from the defense to attack. Bernier had the most passes to Impact forwards in 2012, even more than the more forward playing Felipe. I don't expect Bernier to score as many goals as in 2012, since six of his nine goals came from the penalty spot.

Midfielders
Felipe

Felipe was a huge surprise in 2012 after being virtually an unknown in the lower leagues in Switzerland before joining the Impact. On the downside, Felipe was a leader in missed passes with over 300. He also used refereeing decisions to create some of his chances. I still think he'll play a significant role in 2013 but I would expect a statistical drop off. The other three midfielders have great experience in MLS veterans Justin Mapp, Davy Arnaud and new signing from Italy Andrea Pisanu. The Montreal midfield, like the rest of the team, is as much about holding their opponent as scoring, so expect the team to lead the league in fouls.

Forwards
Marco Di Vaio

Montreal will have a great expectation in Italian forward Marco Di Vaio to score goals. Although he only scored five in 17 games last season, he averaged more than 12 goals per season for top teams in Europe against much stronger defenses than MLS. I expect Di Vaio to score goals and project him to get 14 this season if the team is set up in the fashion that I project based on the team’s playing similar systems around the world.

Bench 

New signing Andres Romero might find a role as a second striker or an attacking midfielder, although the other Montreal substitutes don't necessarily fit the system and might get forgotten in this experiment. Sanna Nyassi was an offensive threat in 2012, but in the current system he might only be a potential substitute for Felipe or Di Vaio if they struggle. Andrew Wenger, Brovsky and Valentin would feel much more comfortable in a traditional MLS set up and, if I was in charge at another club, I would talk to Montreal about acquiring their services.

According to my projected statistics, I have Montreal scoring 43 goals while allowing 49 goals for a +/- of -6 or 14th overall in league. This takes into account that I only expect Nesta to play 2/3 of the Impact games, which exemplifies the biggest concern I have regarding the Impact experiment. It’s great to sign experienced players but in a restricted budget environment it is hard to be consistently good if your team lacks depth. Personally I like some of the moves the Impact have made, although I still predict Montreal to struggle to make the playoffs this season. The big worry is if the experiment doesn't pay off, with a club developed in this fashion, where do you go next?